Frequently Asked Questions
Tell me about the 2025 price increase!
As of January 1st 2025, custom cookie pricing will start at $62 per dozen. If this is shocking to you, then I would suggest doing research in the custom decorative cookie market/ how much local competitors charge for their work. If you have any questions about the price increase, feel free to contact me with any questions. I want to keep my business alive and thriving, and I won’t be able to do that unless I charge what I am worth.
Thank you all so much for your continued business and love of cookies!
How do I order cookies?
Please fill out the inquiry form on this website and I will respond within 48 hours.
How much do the cookies cost?
Pricing is listed under the pricing tab on this site. Cookies start at $50 per dozen and are subjected to up-charges depending on the order details.
I live too far from Cape May, can you ship me cookies?
No. It is illegal to SHIP cookies to customers or to deliver cookies over state lines.
Where can I pick up my cookies?
My home bakery is located in Cape May/Erma area, not too far from the Cape May Brewery.
How far in advance should I order?
Custom orders should be placed with a MINIMUM of 2 weeks advanced notice. Orders can be placed up to 2 months in advance. Weddings/Large Events (100+ cookies) should be placed at least 2 MONTHS before
*Orders placed with LESS than 2 weeks notice will have a $15 rush fee
What’s in the dough?
My dough recipe was created by my maternal grandmother and is in its 3rd generation of baking. Recipe includes all purpose flour, butter, sugar, eggs, salt, baking soda, baking powder, and vanilla extract. GLUTEN FREE cookies are available at a small upcharge for GF flour costs. (GF not suggested for those with ALLERGIES- I do not have a gluten free kitchen)
What’s in the icing?
The icing is not your average decorated cookie icing. IT IS NOT ROYAL ICING. It is called glaze/modified glaze, which consists of powdered sugar, light corn syrup, vanilla extract, and almond milk. The cookies have a soft bite, but the icing dries completely firm and can be packaged tightly.
How many cookies can I order?
ALL custom orders have a minimum amount of 2 dozen cookies. You can order as many as you like, but any orders over 100 cookies needs to be booked at least a month in advance
Holiday cookies or special events?
Various holidays and events will have a presale or a flash sale. If you want to be notified ahead of time, please subscribe to my email list! Not every holiday will have a cookie sale though
How are the cookies packaged?
Cookies are individually heat sealed for freshness and stacked in a bakery box. This allows the cookies to stay fresh for weeks after the pick up date. Cookies can be packaged with bows, in individual boxes, or with tags for an additional cost.
